5 from 4 ratings

Making your own homemade casseroles without cream of mushroom soup is so simple! This non traditional green bean casserole has a creamy sour cream-based sauce and is topped with pan fried shallots for a delicious, healthier alternative to classic green bean casserole. I make this with healthy sweet potato casserole and roasted turkey for a small holiday dinner variation!

baking dish with cooked green bean casserole topped with shallots.

IT'S THE HOLIDAYS GUYS.

Seriously. The most wonderful time of the year and all that jazz.

Recipe Notes

I am a huge fan of very simple casseroles, and traditional green bean casserole is one of my favorite holiday dishes. Occasionally I change up the method with fresh green beans and by making my own sauce instead of using cream of mushroom soup. The result is a very classic flavor but slightly jazzed up - fresh green beans, fresh shallots, and garlic all are delicious in this casserole.

Just like most casseroles, this one sort of gets better as it sits, and you can 100% make the entire thing up until the final bake a few days before Thanksgiving or whatever holiday meal you're making.

This is also a good method to have on hand for times when you'd like a creamy side dish but don't have any cream of mushroom soup - thickened stock with sour cream and seasonings works wonderfully as a substitute for cream of mushroom soup in green bean casserole.

Ingredients

Ingredients: fresh green beans! Or haricots vert! I like thin green beans because they're pretty and cook slightly faster, and I get mine at Trader Joe's, but any green bean that you like is just fine. I cut green beans in half for casseroles so that they are a little closer to bite-sized.

You also need sliced mushrooms and, again, any kind you like goes! You also need butter, garlic, soy sauce, chicken stock, flour, sour cream, and 2 shallots. Then salt and pepper, duh. If you're going to make this dish and bake it right away, preheat the oven to 375F.

Ingredient Notes and Variations

If you'd like to make this vegetarian, sub vegetable stock for the chicken stock.
Use full fat sour cream at all times for the best flavor and texture of the sauce.
If you prefer to not buy a shallot or don't have one, about ⅓ cup of thinly sliced onion can be substituted no problem.
You can use canned green beans if you like! 2 large 28-ounce cans will be the perfect amount for this casserole.
Frozen green beans also work well here, treat them as you would fresh and be sure a good amount of the liquid evaporates from the skillet so the casserole isn't too soupy.
French Fried Onions are classic in this dish, and feel free to use them if you'd like! I love the onion flavor from the pan fried shallots here, but if you like that crispy crunchy topping, grab a can of the classic onions instead!

Step By Step Instructions

First, we'll make our crispy shallot topping. You can do this in a separate pan, but I just used one pan to save on dishes. Add 1 tablespoon of the butter to a skillet to heat up over medium heat.

sliced shallots in a black skillet with butter.

When the butter foams and the pan is hot, add the shallots to the skillet in one layer and sprinkle them with salt. They should sizzle!

Let the shallots cook and crisp for about 3 minutes, then toss them once and let them go for another few minutes. We want some dark bits on the shallots and for them to be mostly crispy.

When the shallots are done, remove them to a little dish to hang out while you prep the filling of the casserole.

skillet of raw mushrooms being cooked down for casserole.

Add another tablespoon of butter to the skillet with the mushrooms. Let them cook for about 7 minutes, stirring the whole time, until they are browned and wilted.

Next, add the green beans to the pan with the mushrooms.

green beans and mushrooms in a large black skillet.

Stir the mushrooms and green beans together and let them cook for a few minutes - how long will depend on how large your green beans are AND how large your skillet is. Stir the green beans every few minutes and let them soften a bit - remember that they'll keep cooking in the oven so they don't need to be totally cooked.

While the green beans are working, mince the garlic and gather up the rest of the ingredients.

skillet of green beans with garlic and butter at the center of the skillet.

When the green beans are just slightly soft (remember they'll cook more in the oven), make a well in the center of the skillet and add another pat of butter and the minced garlic.

flour sprinkled over green beans and mushrooms as a roux.

Then sprinkle the flour over the skillet! The flour mixes with the butter and liquids from the veggies, which will help thicken the stock and form a sauce.

stock being poured into a skillet of green beans.

Stir everything together to incorporate the flour with the butter and garlic, for about 2 minutes. Then, pour the stock slowly over the whole skillet, stirring as you go, to create a gravy.

Last, add in the soy sauce, salt, and sour cream.

skillet with filling for green bean casserole without mushroom soup.

Stir everything together, and taste! Add more salt and pepper if you'd like, or another splash of stock if yours gets really thick.

Pour the mixture into a baking dish...

fresh green bean casserole in baking dish prior to baking.

...and top it with the shallots.

Now, just bake the dish for 20-30 minutes until the beans are soft and the top is slightly dark.

Top view of healthy green bean casserole with fresh shallot topping.

Fresh! I'm a big fan of regular old green bean casserole with the canned soup and fried onions, but this is a really nice alternative, especially if you're part of a gang that does a lot of cream of whatever soup based dishes. Vegetables! Healthy!

Green Bean Casserole Without Cream of Mushroom Soup

Recipe Notes

Ingredients

Ingredient Notes and Variations

Step By Step Instructions

Recipe